Siding Replacement
Upgrade aging, faded, or damaged siding with a fresh exterior designed for Long Island weather.
Explore serviceLocally Owned & Operated
Licensed & Fully Insured
At Brookhaven Siding Pros, we're a locally owned, licensed, and fully insured siding company serving Brookhaven, NY, and the surrounding Long Island communities. We know how important your home is to you, and we believe taking care of it shouldn't have to be stressful. Whether you're dealing with damaged siding, thinking about replacing older panels, or simply looking to give your home a fresh look, we're here to help. We take the time to listen, answer your questions, and make sure you understand your options before any work begins.
Living on Long Island, we know how much wear and tear our homes can take from the weather over the years. That's why we focus on siding solutions that look good and hold up over time. We work with a variety of materials, including vinyl siding, fiber cement, cedar, and composite siding, so you can choose what works best for your home and budget. Whether it's a small siding repair or a complete siding replacement, we approach every project with the same care and attention. If you're not sure where to start, just give us a call. We're always happy to talk through your options and provide a free, no-obligation estimate.

Whether you're dealing with damaged siding or planning a full exterior refresh, explore siding services for homeowners in Brookhaven, NY, and nearby communities.
Upgrade aging, faded, or damaged siding with a fresh exterior designed for Long Island weather.
Explore serviceAddress cracked panels, loose sections, and weather-related damage before small issues grow.
Explore serviceExplore siding options for new projects and exterior upgrades, with a focus on finish and fit.
Explore serviceThree proven siding systems, installed across Brookhaven. Compare the texture, depth and finish of each before you choose what goes on your home.
Compare popular exterior siding materials for homes in Brookhaven, NY. From affordable vinyl to textured cedar and durable fiber cement, explore the appearance, maintenance needs and benefits of each option before planning your siding installation or replacement.
Vinyl siding is a popular, low-maintenance choice for siding installation and replacement in Brookhaven, NY. Explore horizontal or vertical profiles, a wide range of colors, and insulated options for added comfort.
Ask About Vinyl Siding →Cedar siding brings authentic wood grain and a classic Long Island appearance to your home. Available in clapboard and shingle styles, it can be stained or painted but needs regular maintenance to protect against moisture.
Ask About Cedar Wood Siding →Fiber cement siding delivers the painted-wood look with resistance to fire, insects and rot. It is a durable option for siding replacement in Brookhaven, especially when installed with proper flashing and moisture management.
Ask About Fiber Cement Siding →Engineered wood siding combines a textured wood appearance with manufactured panels designed for stability. Choose board-and-batten or lap styles for a distinctive exterior; correct installation and upkeep remain important.
Ask About Engineered Wood Siding →Cedar shake siding adds dimension, texture and timeless curb appeal. This material works well on cottage and coastal-inspired homes around Brookhaven, with staining and maintenance needed to preserve the natural finish.
Ask About Cedar Shake Siding →Composite siding offers a smooth, contemporary finish with product-specific moisture and weather performance. Compare profiles, warranties and upkeep to find a practical siding upgrade for your Brookhaven home.
Ask About Composite Siding →Photos are AI-generated material-style illustrations, not completed Brookhaven Siding Pros projects. Material availability and product specifications should be confirmed before making a selection.
Six siding systems, ranked on what actually drives the decision: installed price per square foot, what the material is made of, and what it costs you to maintain every year. Tap a card to add or remove it from the comparison.
Ranked cheapest first. The bar shows average installed cost per square foot for a typical Brookhaven home.Ranked by lowest yearly upkeep. The bar shows average annual maintenance over the life of the siding.Ranked by longest expected service life with normal maintenance.
Tap any card to include or remove it from the table below.
Best value in each row is highlighted in green.
| Spec | Vinyl | Engineered Wood | Cedar Wood | Fiber Cement | Composite | Cedar Shake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Installed cost / sq ft | $4.50 – $8.00Best | $6.50 – $11.00 | $8.00 – $14.00 | $9.00 – $16.00 | $11.00 – $20.00 | $12.00 – $22.00 |
| Maintenance / yr | $150 – $350 | $200 – $450 | $600 – $1,200 | $150 – $400 | $100 – $300Best | $700 – $1,500 |
| Service life | 20 – 40 yrs | 25 – 40 yrs | 30 – 50 yrs | 30 – 50 yrs | 25 – 40 yrs | 30 – 60 yrsBest |
| What it is made of | Extruded PVC panels with colour-through pigment | Resin-bonded wood strand board, factory primed | Solid Western Red Cedar clapboard | Cement, sand and cellulose fibre | Polymer and wood-fibre panels | Hand-split cedar shakes, 18 to 24 inch |
| Fire / code | Class B typical; softens in extreme heat | Class C; needs primer and paint | Class C untreated; treat in wildfire zones | Class A, non-combustible | Class A, flame resistant | Class C untreated; Class B when treated |
| Best for | Tight budgets and rental properties | A wood look on a mid-range budget | Natural warmth and a traditional look | Low upkeep over 30 plus years | The shake look without repainting | Historic, coastal and character homes |
Ballpark ranges for a typical 2,000 sq ft Long Island home, installed. Removal, trim, height and access all move the number. Call Brookhaven Siding Pros at +1 631-866-0672 for an exact figure on your house.

Your home's siding does more than make it look nice. It's the outer layer that helps protect your house from rain, wind, snow, and the changing temperatures we experience here in Brookhaven, NY. Siding works alongside other parts of your home's exterior, including the weather barrier and insulation, to help keep moisture out and maintain a comfortable indoor environment. It also plays a big role in your home's curb appeal. Whether you have vinyl siding, fiber cement, cedar, or another material, keeping it in good condition is important. Over time, siding can crack, loosen, fade, or become damaged by the weather. Knowing what siding does and recognizing when it needs repair or replacement can help you prevent bigger problems and keep your home looking its best for years to come.
A little about your home's exterior
Siding does more than give your house its look. Along with the layers underneath it, siding helps shield your exterior walls from the weather. Here are a few reasons keeping it in good shape matters here on Long Island.
Winters in Brookhaven, NY, bring cold temperatures, occasional snow and ice, and plenty of changes between freezing and thawing. Over time, those conditions can make existing cracks, loose siding panels, and gaps around trim more noticeable. Water can find its way into vulnerable spots and cause further trouble when temperatures drop.
Good siding installation is only part of the picture. Proper flashing, house wrap, and insulation all work together to help protect the wall beneath. If you notice panels pulling away or damage after winter, it may be worth having the area checked before a small siding repair becomes a bigger project.
Anyone who's been through a windy Long Island storm knows how hard gusts and driving rain can hit a house. That can be especially tough on siding that's already loose, cracked, or nearing the end of its life. Once one panel comes free, the exposed area may be more vulnerable to the next storm.
Whether you're looking into siding repair or siding replacement in Brookhaven, proper fastening and careful installation around corners, windows, and doors make a difference. After a storm, take a look from the ground for shifted panels or exposed areas, and have any concerns checked safely.
Brookhaven homes deal with rain, humidity, and, in some areas, salty coastal air. Siding helps shed water, but it isn't meant to do the job alone. The weather-resistant barrier, flashing, and drainage details behind the panels are just as important for managing moisture.
If you see cracked siding, soft trim, stains, or panels that won't stay in place, it's worth finding out why. Water trapped behind an exterior wall can eventually contribute to mold or wood rot. Catching the problem early can help you decide whether a targeted siding repair is enough or a larger section needs replacing.
Siding is one of the first things people notice about a house. Whether you have a classic Long Island ranch, a Cape-style home, or something more modern, the color and profile you choose can change its whole appearance without changing what you love about it.
For homeowners considering vinyl siding, fiber cement siding, cedar, or composite siding, we can help talk through the look, upkeep, and budget for each material. Sometimes a repair and a little attention to the trim are all you need. Other times, new siding is a chance to give your home a fresh start.
Not sure what your siding needs? We're happy to talk it through.
Get a Free Estimate →Choosing a siding contractor is an important decision, and we know you want someone you can trust with your home. Plenty of contractors can install siding, but it's how they treat you and your home that makes the difference. Here are four things we do differently at Brookhaven Siding Pros. Tap any reason to learn what you can expect when working with us.
Tell us about your property and a Brookhaven siding specialist will call you back with a written, no-obligation estimate.
Cost and timing are the two things Brookhaven homeowners ask about first. Here is exactly how we price a project and how long the crew will be on your property, so there is nothing left to guess at before you request your estimate.
Free written estimates. No pressure, no obligation.
Every home is measured on site, so pricing depends on your square footage, the material you choose, the condition of the existing siding and how much trim work is involved. Instead of a phone-ballpark number, you get an itemized written estimate that separates materials, labor and removal, so you can see exactly where the money goes before you commit.
Most single-family Brookhaven homes are finished in 3 to 7 working days once materials are delivered. Larger homes, multiple rooflines or extensive trim detailing can extend that window, and we confirm your specific timeline in writing with the estimate so you can plan around it.
Panels carry their manufacturer warranty, which varies by material and can run up to a lifetime for premium lines. That coverage sits on top of our own written workmanship warranty, which covers the installation itself. We hand over both documents at completion and walk you through what each one covers.
Yes. We review payment schedules and available financing during your estimate so the project fits your budget rather than the other way around. There are no surprise add-ons after the contract is signed: the written estimate is the number you pay.
The crew stages materials in one agreed area, protects plantings and walkways, and cleans the site at the end of every working day. Weather is the one factor we cannot schedule around, so if a storm interrupts the install we tell you immediately and reset the completion date in writing.